Sugardarlings requires all orders be placed over the phone or in person at one of our shops. Facebook and e-mail are not an acceptable form of placing an order. We want to ensure your order is placed in time for your special event, so please call within 72 hours prior to your pick up date. We will do our absolute best to try to accommodate any last minute orders, so PLEASE CALL US! Our shop numbers can be found on our contact page. Please keep in mind that our shops open at 11:30am, and all shops are closed on Sundays & Mondays. Thinking of holding your next event at Sugardarlings? Click Here for pricing information to rent one of our locations for your next party! We can even accommodate large corporate events and fundraisers!
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a Lil' Darling?
We've renamed our mini cupcakes to our Lil' Darling Cupcakes because they truly are the perfect size and they are not very tiny at all! Our shops carry Lil' Darlings on a daily basis in a wide variety of flavors in a more affordable price ($1.25 each). They are slightly smaller than a standard size cupcake, but they are still baked with extra love! Perfect size for weddings, birthdays, and any special occasion. Most flavors are filled with our signature fillings. When you walk in and purchase from our case, you will save each time you buy a pack of 9 Lil' Darlings. A pack of 9 Lil' Darlings is $10 (you save $1.25), a pack of 18 Lil' Darlings is $20 (You save $2.50), a pack of 27 Lil' Darlings is $30 (you save $3.75)!
What is a Love Muffin?
Our signature standard size cupcakes have always been nicknamed "Love Muffins" since Jessica Beebe opened her doors in New Port Richey. They are called Love Muffins because of the tremendous amount of love that us put into baking and decorating them. If you haven't already tried our cupcakes, you will soon understand what we mean! Our cake is known for being extremely moist and not too sweet. Just the perfect balance of flavor and texture when you bite into one of our Love Muffins. The Love Muffin size cupcakes are a standard size, and almost all of the flavors are filled with a frosting or filling. The only flavor we simply cannot fill are the Cannoli Love Muffins.
We no longer carry our Love Muffins in our shops daily, but they are always available for special orders! Call today to place your order. We normally need 2 days notice to accommodate your special request!
Banana Cream Pie
Banana Peanut Butter (Elvis)
Blueberry Lavender Cheesecake
Boston Cream Pie
Brown Sugar Cinnamon
Peaches & Cream
Peanut Butter Jelly
Peanut Butter Lover
Peanut Butter Blossom
Pumpkin Brulee (Seasonal)
Chocolate Covered Banana
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
Chocolate Cream Pie
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Coconut Cream Pie
Coffee & Donut
Cookies & Cream
Egg Nog (seasonal)
Hot Fudge Sundae
Key Lime Pie
Key Lime Cookie
Root Beer Float
Sex on the Beach*
Stuffed Banana Nut French Toast
White Chocolate Raspberry
White Chocolate Lavender
& SO MANY MORE FLAVORS!!!
These are just a few of our flavors. We are constantly creating new and exciting flavors in our kitchen.
If there is something you do not see, please let us know and we will happily bake a batch just for you!
All of our cupcakes are filled with something special. Fillings vary depending on the flavor.
Please call us if you have any questions.
Note: Some flavors are seasonal. *Flavors marked may contain alcohol and/or cost extra. Flavors in bold are popular.
PLEASE note: Not all of our flavors can be made into a sugar-free or gluten-free alternative. Please call us to find out more about your options for specialty flavors that are available. We do offer dairy-free on a daily basis (our Chocolate Chocolate cupcakes are made with a non-dairy whipped mousse frosting). Other dairy-free options are available by special orders. All of our cupcakes are baked in a facility where we handle peanuts. If you have a extremely sensitive peanut allergy, please order your cupcakes ahead and we will take EXTRA precautions with your order. Thank you!
Our Love Muffin Flavor List
Ordering in Advance:
Lil' Darlings are $12 per dozen (must be one flavor per dozen)
Gluten Free Lil' Darlings are $16 per dozen (must be one flavor per dozen)
Cocktail / Specialty Lil' Darlings are $16 per dozen (contains alcohol in the cupcake)
Love Muffins are $16 per dozen (when you order one flavor per dozen)
Love Muffins are $20 per dozen (when you split your dozen into 2 flavors)
Gluten Free / Specialty / Cocktail Love Muffins are $24 per dozen
If you have any questions about our specialty cupcakes, please call us! We are available to chat Tuesday - Saturday 11:30am to 8pm 727-785-2253.
Visiting our Shop:
We are currently offering our Lil' Darlings in our shops. They are the perfect size to enjoy without all of the guilt of eating a whole cupcake by yourself! See for yourself when you stop in to one of our three locations. We are proud to offer a variety of dozens of flavors daily so you will always have a fresh exciting assortment to select from our case. A smaller size = more fun options for you to select!
Lil Darlings are $1.25 each
Pack of 9 Lil' Darlings $10 (you save $1.25)
Pack of 18 Lil' Darlings $20 (you save $2.50)
Pack of 27 Lil' Darlings $30 (you save $3.75)
Our goal is to provide our customers with a tremendous amount of cupcake flavors and quantities on a daily basis so you can swing by and pick out a significant amount of fun flavors to share for your last minute gatherings.